Trump’s new-old strategy towards Russia and Ukraine
In recent days, US President Donald Trump has made a series of gestures and concessions towards Russia. He has decided to suspend sanctions, allowing Russian diesel exports to the US and other countries, and has refrained from imposing new ones under the so-called Graham Act. Alongside these concessions to Moscow, his administration has pressured Ukraine to halt its attacks on Russian oil refineries and hold elections, while also criticising President Volodymyr Zelensky. Reports have also emerged that the US has suspended intelligence sharing with Ukraine and imposed restrictions on its use of the Starshield system, although the US administration has denied deliberately taking these measures. Meanwhile, Steve Witkoff has resumed his peace efforts, holding talks with Ukrainian officials in Miami and Oslo and with Russian officials in St Petersburg. However, the discussions have produced no agreements.
These steps towards Russia should be viewed in the context of the US congressional midterm elections, which are of crucial importance to President Trump. The US administration’s underlying strategy towards the Russia-Ukraine war has not changed, but the concessions to Vladimir Putin have deepened the personal rift between the US and Ukrainian presidents. Zelensky’s decision to continue attacks on Russian oil refineries and his critical assessment of US concessions to Russia have further exacerbated these tensions. Kyiv hopes that the situation will change after the US elections. In the meantime, it is seeking to limit the damage and increase pressure on the Trump administration to revise its approach to supporting Ukraine by highlighting the inconsistencies in Washington’s policy. It also aims to mobilise greater European assistance.
The US administration’s approach to ending the war
The Trump administration’s strategy towards Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has not fundamentally changed in recent months. Washington remains committed to ending the war. Successive attempts to reach an agreement with Moscow have led to periods of improved relations between the US and Russia, as well as moments of rapprochement between Washington and Kyiv that were most likely intended to exert pressure on Russia and persuade Putin to make concessions.
The decision taken in the spring of 2026 to temporarily ease sanctions on Russian oil transported by tankers from the so-called shadow fleet demonstrated that the Trump administration is willing to accept short-term benefits for Moscow and a stronger Russian position vis-à-vis Kyiv if this could mitigate the impact of the energy market crisis triggered by the war with Iran and bolster the US president’s domestic political standing. The same calculation underpins both the ‘diesel deal’ and the contemplated suspension of sanctions on the Russian and Iranian shadow fleets. Another factor that may have influenced Trump’s decision to reach an agreement with Moscow is his desire to limit Russian assistance to Iran, as he suggested in one of his posts on Truth Social.
The decision to suspend existing sanctions and refrain from imposing new ones under the Graham Act, which was due to come into force on 18 October, was a predictable move. The legislation was intended to signal to Russia that the White House had more drastic measures at its disposal but would refrain from using them as long as President Trump believed that the negotiations could succeed.
The Trump administration has also cited progress in peace talks as a justification for easing sanctions. In its view, the release of an American citizen and Russia’s agreement to resume trilateral talks demonstrate that avoiding actions likely to antagonise Moscow can produce positive results. Meanwhile, discussions with Ukrainian officials have continued in Miami and Oslo. Commentators sympathetic to the current US administration also see President Zelensky’s stated willingness to meet Putin and Trump as further evidence that its approach towards Russia and Ukraine is working. This interpretation shapes perceptions of these developments among Trump’s supporters and may reinforce the administration’s confidence in its own strategy.
The dispute between Presidents Trump and Zelensky has the potential to escalate. From the perspective of the current US administration, Ukraine’s decision to continue attacking Russian oil refineries shows disregard for the US president’s political interests. Its refusal to halt these attacks and Zelensky’s angry responses to Trump’s actions have prompted the US president to adopt a more uncompromising stance, as he cannot afford to appear weak in the eyes of the American public or be seen as accepting terms dictated by Ukraine. This shift also aligns with the hostility towards the Ukrainian leader among the American far right.
Republicans face the risk of electoral defeat
The upcoming US congressional midterm elections provide the critical context for Trump’s decision to reach an agreement with Russia on diesel supplies. The Republicans risk losing control of both chambers of Congress, but the final outcome is difficult to predict because of the way US elections are organised. Senate elections take place in only some states, while politically motivated changes to the boundaries of House of Representatives districts, a practice known as gerrymandering, in many cases effectively preclude genuine electoral competition. Nevertheless, there is little doubt that the Republicans are in an exceptionally weak position, trailing the Democrats by an average of around nine percentage points in opinion polls.
Another problem for the Republican Party is Trump’s low approval rating, which currently stands at around 36% according to polling averages. Several factors have contributed to this, but one of the most important is high fuel prices resulting from the conflict with Iran. High diesel prices are particularly significant, as they are hitting American farmers, a key segment of Trump’s electoral base that has already suffered from the tariff war and the loss of cheap labour owing to his administration’s immigration and deportation policies. By focusing on Ukrainian attacks targeting Russian oil refineries, Trump can shift the blame for high fuel prices onto President Zelensky. The agreement with Russia serves to reinforce the narrative that the US president is capable of delivering results and that the situation will soon improve. In this context, the actual impact of the agreement, which will not bring down diesel prices, matters far less than its propaganda value. Trump may also benefit politically from the release of an American prisoner.
However, Republican voters may not necessarily welcome the rapprochement with Russia. According to a Pew Research Center survey, 47% of Republican respondents view Russia as an enemy, with the proportion considerably higher among older voters, while only 10% regard Russia as a partner. In a separate YouGov poll, 55% of Republican voters described Ukraine as an ally or a country friendly to the United States. This disconnect between the president’s decisions and sentiment among Republican voters is also evident in the positions taken by some Republican politicians. Although relatively few have chosen to challenge the president on this issue, those who have done so – apart from politicians not seeking re-election – are primarily Republicans representing districts and states where this year’s electoral contests are most competitive.
Ukraine’s response to Trump’s latest decisions
Following the shouting match in the Oval Office in February 2025, Zelensky sought to avoid open conflict with Trump. He emphasised his willingness to end the war and accepted US proposals aimed at advancing this goal, hoping that this would help maintain Washington’s support, expose Moscow’s obstructive stance and persuade Trump to exert pressure on Russia. However, Trump’s decision to resume Russian diesel supplies, coupled with pressure on Kyiv, has sparked a fresh wave of frustration in Ukraine and further heightened tensions in its relations with the US. President Zelensky is struggling to maintain a constructive tone and, despite criticising the US position, is refraining from attacking Trump directly, as Kyiv’s priorities in its relations with the US remain largely unchanged. These include maintaining the ability to purchase weapons, particularly scarce missiles for Patriot air defence systems, and retaining access to US intelligence and the Starshield satellite communications system.
Kyiv has highlighted the alleged US restrictions, portraying them as a means of exerting pressure and even an attempt to force Ukraine into capitulation. According to Ukrainian officials, the suspension of intelligence sharing has hampered the country’s ability to defend itself against Russian ballistic missile attacks, while restrictions on access to satellite communications have impeded efforts to counter Russian attack drones and operate medium-range unmanned aerial vehicles, which are crucial to disrupting Russian logistics. However, it is impossible to determine whether the reported problems with early warning of Russian missile attacks actually occurred and, if so, whether they resulted from technical issues or deliberate US action. Moreover, data from Ukraine’s Air Force Command do not support claims that limitations on Starshield connection speeds have reduced the effectiveness of Ukrainian efforts to counter Russian drones or carry out strikes.
Meanwhile, Kyiv is still seeking to demonstrate that Moscow is sabotaging Washington’s peace initiatives and continuing its attacks on Ukrainian energy infrastructure despite Trump’s announcement of a mutual ceasefire in this sector. After a three-day unilateral pause, Ukraine resumed strikes on Russian oil refineries, while declaring its readiness to halt them again only if Russia reciprocates. Kyiv’s willingness to freeze the conflict along the current front line and hold elections is also intended to expose Russia’s professed willingness to make peace as insincere. Ukraine has been publicly highlighting US pressure on Kyiv and concessions to Russia in an effort to persuade Trump to change his approach and mobilise greater European assistance.
Zelensky hopes that the pressure on Ukraine is temporary and forms part of the campaign ahead of the 3 November midterm elections, which could alter the balance of power in Congress. At the same time, some of his critical remarks about Trump serve a domestic purpose, as he seeks to rebuild public support weakened by corruption scandals involving members of his inner circle. According to a survey conducted by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology between 8 and 16 October, 54% of respondents expressed trust in Zelensky, while 41% said they did not trust him. Following the announcement of the Trump–Putin agreement and the intensification of US pressure, the proportion of respondents expressing support for Zelensky rose from 43% on 8–9 October to 57% on 10–16 October.